|
|
|
|
|
|
The Confederacy's Last Hurrah: Spring Hill, Franklin, and Nashville (Modern War Studies) written by Wiley Sword Studio : University Press of Kansas by University Press of Kansas Publisher : University Press of Kansas Released : 1993-10 Availability : Usually ships in 1-2 business days Number of Items : 1 EAN : 9780700606504 Avg. Customer Rating: (based on 37 reviews)
List Price : $16.95 Our Price : $10.93
|
|
| |
|
Product Description |
|
Originally published as Embrace an Angry Wind Following the fall of Atlanta, rebel commander John Bell Hood rallied his demoralized troops and marched them off the Tennessee, desperately hoping to draw Sherman after him and forestall the Confederacy's defeat. But Sherman refused to be lured and began his infamous "March to the Sea," while Hood charged headlong into catastrophe. In this compelling dramatic account of a final and fatal invasion by the Confederate Army of Tennessee, Wile Sword illuminates the missed opportunities, senseless bloody assaults, poor command decisions, and stubborn pride that resulted in 23,500 Confederate losses--including 7,00 casualties in one battle-- and the pulverization of the South's second largest army. Sword follows Hood and his army as they let an early advantage and possible victory slip away at Spring Hill, then engage in a reckless and ill-fated frontal attack on Franklin, often called the "Gettysburg of the West." Despite that disaster, Hood refuses to yield and presses on the Nashville and a two-day bloodbath that unhinges what is left of his battered troops--the worst defeat suffered by any army during the war. Telling the story from both the Confederate and the Union perspectives, Sword pursues personalities as well as battles and troop strategy. He portrays Hood as a gutsy yet irresponsible leader--"a fool with a license to kill his own men"--whose valiant but rapidly dwindling troops were no match for the methodical General George G. Thomas and his better prepared--and entrenched--Union army. Hood, however, was not entirely to blame for Confederate failures, says Sword, who shows how decision making and actions--both good and bad, logical and chaotic--by key players on both sides helped determine the battles' outcomes. This book is part of the Modern War Studies series. |
| |
|
| |
|
Break an Angry Wind |
This book was originally entitled "Embrace an Angry Wind: The Confederacy's Last Hurrah." I'm not sure what an angry wind is supposed to be, but "Hurrah" is something a Union soldier would have shouted. A Confederate soldier would probably have shouted, "Wooo-hooo-weeee" or something to that effect.
Sword is apparently a tireless researcher and very skilled at weaving the primary sources into a gripping narrative. Therefore I can go no lower than two stars. I can go no higher than two, however, because of his book-long ad hominem rant against Hood.
I'm OK with the old stock opinions about Hood being past his level as an army commander, or Mary Chesnut's tales of his unlucky love affair with Buck Preston, or his secret correspondence with Richmond. Sword goes well beyond this by saying that Hood was "a fool with a license to kill his own men." Is there anything comparable to that in the Civil War literature said about a Union general, or even another Southern one for that matter?
|
| |
|
General's Rank ? |
Promotion of the generals in the Civil War was not any different than promotions are today in the military, government, business, and the rest of the world. You will find that in Grant's and Lee's armies there were many generals passed over because of some conflict with those of higher rank. The men they touted for promotions were not always the best to fill a leadership position. Some may have been very brave soldiers but not a leader. Through out the war there were some wrong men giving the orders, orders misunderstood, changed, not carried out, and the wrong order given. Maybe some battles could have been changed and had fewer casualties, but not the outcome of the war. Franklin was the most tragic battle of our Civil War. By Ruth Thompson author of "The Bluegrass Dream" and "Natchez Above The River"
Writing as a Small BusinessQualifying Laps: A Brewster County NovelSins of the Fathers: A Brewster County NovelTravelersThe Bluegrass Dream: A Wilderness Adventure of Early Settlers
|
| |
|
One of the Best |
|
In The Confederacy's Last Hurrah, Wiley Sword covers political intrigue, strategy and tactics, and the view from the trenches equally well. My great-great grandfather fought at Franklin and Nashville, and through Sword's work, I was able to observe, from the safety of my living room, the agony, terror, carnage, and unbelievable courage of the men on both sides. He has thoroughly researched Hood's campaign through Tennessee, yet manages not to lose the reader in details. Maps are clear and easy to follow. I recommend this book wholeheartedly to anyone wanting a better understanding of the war's final days in the West. |
| |
|
Outstanding read... |
|
I am a young civil war enthusist and have never really studied the end of the Confederate Army of the Tennessee. This book opens the door into one of the saddest few months of any army during the Civil War. Very in depth and throughly reserched. Spends ample time on the decisive Battle of Franklin and incorprates not only the eyewitness accounts from officers, but the privates in the thick of the fight. Recommened for any Civil War enthusist. |
| |
|
Fascinating and readable account of disaster in the |
|
Some people who have read this book with a jaundiced eye have criticized Sword for his accurate protrayal of John Bell Hood. Davis like the present president had favorites to whom he remained faithful despite their obvious shortcommings. As Sword points out Hood was a great general as a field commander but even before his physical injuries he was not suited to command an independent army. As radical Confederate Louis Wigfall commented, "Davis has attempted to do what God couldn't; male John Hood a general." If someone wants to understand the imprortance of the West and the disaster made by Hood, this book is required reading. It is not recommended for hero worshipers. |
| |
|
|
|